When Mesut Özil joined Arsenal in 2013, it was supposed to be a watershed moment where the club pushed on and moved to the next level in the transfer market.

To try and evaluate whether things have worked out as planned, we’re looking at all the permanent signings made since the German international joined and whether they’ve been a hit or a miss so far.

Mathieu Debuchy – Miss

Debuchy has made 26 appearances for Arsenal in over three seasons. His injuries and inconsistent form have prevented him from making an impact at the Gunners.

David Ospina – Miss

Ospina was signed after a fantastic set of performances at the World Cup, but has never really lived up to the hype created by that tournament.

ospina west brom

He’s still caught out regularly in ways he shouldn’t be, so I feel he’s been a lacklustre signing in truth.

Alexis Sanchez – Hit

He may be trying to force his way out of the club at the moment, but for less than £40m Alexis has been an undisputed hit in terms of value for money and impact on the trophy cabinet.

Krystian Bielik – Undecided

Bielik has looked quality for the youth teams at times, but he still hasn’t had many chances for the first-team. He’s still only 19, and could have a big future ahead of him.

Gabriel Paulista – Miss

Gabriel had his fans during his time with the Gunners, and still does, but he never fully integrated with the club and ended up leaving not long later.

Calum Chambers – Undecided

Calum is another who looks to have a big future ahead of him, but he’s only really shown his quality in his first few games for the Gunners and on a loan spell at Middlesbrough.

calum chambers v doncaster

We’re yet to see how he does playing at centre-back in North London, hopefully we’ll see the best of him at that stage.

Danny Welbeck – Undecided

I can’t bring myself to put Welbeck in the ‘miss’ category because I really do like him, but he’s been out injured for far too long to be classed as a hit.

Arsenal had more than enough injury problems before Danny joined, and unfortunately he’s just added to them. His goals against Manchester United and Leicester City were very memorable and he works hard whenever he plays, however.

Petr Čech – Hit

I know this will cause controversy given how unpopular Petr is at the moment, but the former Chelsea man is still clearly the best keeper Arsenal have had for a while, in my opinion.

The likes of Manuel Almunia and Lukasz Fabianski don’t come close, and Szczesny only did when he went on loan. Čech has been a miss in the penalty department, but he’s just a scapegoat for poor defending most of the rest of the time.

Mohamed Elneny – Undecided

If we judge Elneny as a squad option then he’s been a hit. He’s been willing to step in wherever required, and almost never been the worst player on the pitch.

Elneny Egypt
Egypt’s midfielder Mohamed Elneny celebrates scoring the first goal of the match during the 2017 Africa Cup of Nations final football match between Egypt and Cameroon at the Stade de l’Amitie Sino-Gabonaise in Libreville on February 5, 2017. Picture: ISSOUF SANOGO/AFP/Getty Images

If we judge Mo as a potential starter, he’s a miss, because he’s never shown enough to push Arsenal to the next level.

Lucas Perez – Miss

Perez did very well when he started matches, but he almost never started for Arsenal, and now he’s gone.

Takuma Asano – Miss

Asano hasn’t been particularly impressive on his loans to Stuttgart, and hasn’t played a single match for the Gunners. He may be young, at 22, but he hasn’t shown enough so far.

Granit Xhaka – Undecided

Again, not a fan favourite, but Xhaka has been a regular in the Arsenal first-team, and had to play a position he’s not used to. I think we’ll see better from him, and I certainly prefer him to Francis Coquelin or Elneny.

Rob Holding – Hit

For the price, and for his age, Rob Holding was a great piece of business. He may be suffering a bit at the moment, but he’s already been a key factor in one trophy success, and hopefully has more to come.

Shkodran Mustafi – Miss

Conversely, considering how much Mustafi cost Arsenal, the fact he had an average first season and then tried to leave at the end of it suggests he hasn’t been very good value at all.

Alexandre Lacazette – Hit

Six goals from nine starts is a quality return from a new striker, and he’s the only player putting them away consistently at the moment. Scoring in a big away game against the league leaders doesn’t hurt either.

Sead Kolašinac – Hit

Sead has contributed to just as many goals as Lacazette so far, with three goals and three assists.


In total, that makes five hits and six misses. I want to see more before coming to a conclusion. It does seem that the business has improved, but perhaps that’s just because we haven’t had enough time to fully evaluate the new signings.

Hopefully that’s not the case, and the Gunners really are becoming a team that only sign players who can improve the first eleven. That hasn’t been the case so far.