Arsenal looked set for a legal battle over a bonus clause in their contract with Saint-Etienne for the transfer of William Saliba, according to reports in France but talk has cooled.

ST ALBANS, ENGLAND - SEPTEMBER 13: William Saliba of Arsenal during a training session at London Colney on September 13, 2019 in St Albans, England. (Photo by Stuart MacFarlane/Arsenal FC via Getty Images)
ST ALBANS, ENGLAND: William Saliba of Arsenal during a training session at London Colney on September 13, 2019. (Photo by Stuart MacFarlane/Arsenal FC via Getty Images)

L’Equipe (via GFFN) claimed Arsenal and Saint-Etienne agreed on the now-contentious clause as part of a couple of bonuses in their William Saliba deal last summer, in addition to the original €25m fee.

The first was that Arsenal will owe Saint-Etienne €2.5m if they qualify for the Champions League whilst Saliba is under contract with them. In the end, they finished 17th so that’s not an issue.

The second was another €2.5m if Saliba made 17 starts this season in all competitions. Arsenal wanted to ensure the centre-back would play regularly on loan, so they decided to include the clause.

William Saliba applauding the fans (Photo via Saliba on Instagram)
William Saliba applauding the fans (Photo via Saliba on Instagram)

Initially, Arsenal actually pushed for 30 appearances, but they also wanted the Ligue 1 club to request permission to play Saliba more than once a week. The two clubs eventually agreed this was too restrictive and compromised on the 17 starts clause.

Saliba only made 16 starts, however, largely thanks to a couple of injuries and the early end to the season.

To make things more complicated, Saint-Etienne wanted Saliba to play in their Coupe de France final against PSG in August hence the ongoing wranglings between the two sides over whether he could play or not.

Saliba could have started that match, but only if Arsenal agreed to loan him back temporarily. Not, however, if it was going cost them €2.5m and in the end Saliba didn’t play with other concerns given as the reason.

There is also the argument that Saint-Etienne followed the spirit of the clause, starting Saliba as often as possible, and it was only circumstances beyond their control that stopped them fulfilling it.

The debate over this interpretation could lead to a legal dispute for the money. With the extra financial pressure on both clubs as a result of the pandemic, this isn’t great timing.

  • This article was updated on 17 August to reflect developments.
Arsenal money

Arsenal’s value grows 23% despite terrible on-pitch decline

Arsenal have placed 38th in Forbes' latest list of the world's most valuable sports clubs with a value of $2.8billion (£1.98billion), representing a 23% rise.

2 Arsenal men called up to Olympic squad could impact next season

Gabriel Magalhaes and Gabriel Martinelli have been called up for the Brazil u23s later this month, ahead of the Olympic games later this summer.
BRENTFORD, ENGLAND - JULY 29: David Raya of Brentford during the Sky Bet Championship Play Off Semi-final 2nd Leg match between Brentford and Swansea City at Griffin Park on July 29, 2020 in Brentford, England. (Photo by Catherine Ivill/Getty Images)

Arsenal identify 2 Bernd Leno replacements at Brentford and Ajax

Arsenal are looking at both Andre Onana and David Raya as possible alternatives to Bernd Leno this summer, according to reports.
Miguel Azeez in first-team training with Arsenal (Photo via Azeez on Instagram)

Arsenal to hand Miguel Azeez first-team place

Although Arsenal are looking to make midfield signings this summer, Miguel Azeez is also expected to step up next season.
Martin Odegaard celebrating scoring for Arsenal against Olympiacos (Photo via Arsenal on Twitter)

Martin Odegaard wants to stay at Arsenal

Martin Odegaard would like to stay with Arsenal this summer, but a number of factors are likely to make that transfer difficult for him.